Debating Prophethood: Ibn al-Malāḥimī’s Critique to Muslim Philosophers
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.69900/ag.v6i1.468Keywords:
prophecy, Islamic philosophy, Ibn al-Malahimi, Mu'tazilaAbstract
Medieval Muslim thinkers sought to defend the necessity of prophecy, especially against external critiques, as prophecy constitutes a central tenet of Islam. Within the Muslim intellectual tradition, however, significant debate surrounds key theological teachings including the doctrine of prophecy itself. This paper aims to reveal the debate, focusing specifically on the critique of Ibn al-Malāḥimī, a prominent figure within the Mu'tazila school, who challenges the prophetic theory of Muslim philosophers. While previous studies have addressed aspects of Ibn al-Malāḥimī's thought, none have thoroughly examined his specific objections to the philosophical interpretations of prophecy. This study employs qualitative research methods, by using Ibn al-Malāḥimī’s Tuḥfah al-Mutakallimīn as its main source. Data collection was conducted through extensive literature study. The findings of this paper reveal that Ibn al-Malāḥimī's critique of the Muslim philosophers' theories of prophecy centers on four key points: (1) the nature of prophecy itself, and (2) the role of prophets as agents of human’s worldly goodness. These critiques are further connected to his opposition to (3) the philosophers' views on the nature of soul and (4) their fatalistic worldview which he argues negates necessarily human free will.
References
‘Abd al-Jabbār, Al-Qāḍī. Al-Mughnī Fī Abwāb al-Tawḥīd Wa al-‘Adl: Al-Taklīf. Edited by Muḥammad ‘Alī Al-Najjār and ‘Abd al-Ḥalīm Al-Najjār. XI. Al-Dār al-Miṣriyyah li al-Ta’līf wa al-Tarjamah, 1961.
‘Abd al-Jabbār, Al-Qāḍī. “Faḍl Al-I‘tizāl Wa Ṭabaqāt al-Mu‘tazilah Wa Mubāyanatuhum Li Sā‘ir al-Mukhālifīn.” In Faḍl Al-I‘tizāl Wa Ṭabaqāt al-Mu‘tazilah, by Abū al-Qāsim ‘Abdullāh ibn Aḥmad Al-Balkhī, Al-Qāḍī ‘Abd al-Jabbār, and Al-Ḥākim Al-Jushamī. Dār al-Fārābī, 2017.
Akyol, Mustafa. Reopening Muslim Minds: A Return to Reason, Freedom and Tolerance. St Martin’s Essentials, 2021.
Al-‘Askarī, Abū Hilāl. Al-Awā’il. Edited by Muḥammad al-Sayyid Al-Wakīl. Dār al-Bashīr, 1987.
Al-Baghdādī, ‘Abd al-Qāhir. Al-Farq Bayn al-Firaq. Edited by ‘Alī ‘Abd al-Bāsiṭ Mazīd. Maktabah al-Īmān, 2015.
Al-Balkhī, Abū al-Qāsim ‘Abdullāh ibn Aḥmad. “Dhikr Al-Mu‘tazilah Min Kitāb al-Maqālāt.” In Faḍl Al-I‘tizāl Wa Ṭabaqāt al-Mu‘tazilah, by Abū al-Qāsim ‘Abdullāh ibn Aḥmad Al-Balkhī, Al-Qāḍī ‘Abd al-Jabbār, and Al-Ḥākim Al-Jushamī, edited by Fu’ād Sayyid. Dār al-Fārābī, 2017.
Al-Balkhī, Abū al-Qāsim ‘Abdullāh ibn Aḥmad. Kitāb Al-Maqālāt Wa Ma‘ahū ‘Uyūn al-Masā’Il Wa al-Jawābāt. Edited by Ḥusayn Khānṣū, Rājiḥ Kurdī, and ‘Abd al-Ḥamīd Kurdī. Kuramer, 2018.
Al-Ghazālī, Abū Ḥāmid. Al-Munqiẓ Min al-Ḍalāl Wa al-Mufṣiḥ Bi al-Aḥwāl. Dār al-Minhāj, 2015.
Al-Ghazālī, Abū Ḥāmid. Maqāṣid Al-Falāsifah. Edited by Mahmoud Piegeot. Maṭba‘ah al-Ṣabāḥ, 2000.
Al-Ghazālī, Abū Ḥāmid. Tahāfut Al-Falāsifah. 3rd ed. Edited by Sulaymān Dunyā. Dār al-Ma‘ārif, 1957.
Al-Isfirāyīnī, Abū al-Muẓaffar. Al-Tabṣīr Fī al-Dīn Wa Tamyīz Firaq al-Nājiyah ‘an al-Firaq al-Hālikah. Edited by Kamāl Yūsuf Al-Ḥūt. ‘Ālam al-Kutub, 1983.
Al-Jishumī, Al-Ḥākim. “Al-Ṭabaqatān al-Ḥādiyah ‘Ashrah Wa al-Thāniyah ‘Ashrah Min Kitāb Sharḥ ‘Uyūn al-Masā’Il.” In Faḍl Al-I‘tizāl Wa Ṭabaqāt al-Mu‘tazilah, by Abū al-Qāsim ‘Abdullāh ibn Aḥmad Al-Balkhī, Al-Qāḍī ‘Abd al-Jabbār, and Al-Ḥākim Al-Jishumī. Dār al-Fārābī, 2017.
Al-Rāwī, ‘Abd al-Sattār ‘Izz al-Dīn. Thawrah Al-A‘ql: Dirāsah Falsafiyyah Fī Fikr Mu‘tazilah Baghdād. Dār al-Shu’ūn al-Thaqafiyyah al-‘Āmmah, 1987.
Al-Rāzī, Abū Bakr. Rasā’il Falsafiyyah. Edited by Paulus Kraus. Al-Maktabah al-Murtaḍawiyyah, n.d.
Al-Rāzī, Fakhr al-Dīn. I‘tiqādāt Firaq al-Muslimīn Wa al-Mushrikīn. Edited by ‘Alī Sāmī Al-Nashshār. Dār al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah, 1982.
Al-Samarqandī, Shams al-Dīn. Bishārāt Al-Ishārāt Fī Sharḥ al-Ishārāt Wa al-Tanbīhāt Li al-Shaykh al-Ra’īs Abī ‘Alī Ḥusayn Ibn ‘Abd Allāh Ibn Sīnā. Vol. 2. Mīrāth Maktūb, 2020.
Al-Shahrastānī, Abū al-Fatḥ Muḥammad ibn ‘Abd al-Karīm. Al-Milal Wa al-Niḥal. Edited by Amīr ‘Alī Mahnā and ‘Alī Ḥasan Fā‘ūr. Dār al-Ma‘rifah, 1993.
Ansari, Hassan, and Sabine Schmidtke. “Sixth/Twelfth-Century Zaydī Theologians of Yemen Debating Avicennan Philosophy.” Shii Studies Review 5, nos. 1–2 (2021): 217–69. https://doi.org/10.1163/24682470-12340068.
Ayub. “Mu’tazila in Western Scholarship: Their Origin, Originality, and Legacy.” Taqaddumi: Journal of Quran and Hadith Studies 1, no. 2 (2021): 80–91. https://doi.org/10.12928/taqaddumi.v1i2.4676.
Eichner, Heidrun. “Scepticisms in the Formation of Islamic Rational Theology: Abū al-Qāsim al-Balkhī and Ibn al-Malāḥimī Providing a Window on the Transmission of Arguments from Late Antiquity.” Theoria 88, no. 1 (2021): 49–71. https://doi.org/10.1111/theo.12322.
Elkaisy-Friemuth, Maha. God and Humans in Islamic Thought: ‘Abd al-Jabbār, Ibn Sīnā and Al-Ghazālī. Routledge, 2006.
Elkaisy-Friemuth, Maha. “The Human and the Prophet in Abd Al-Jabbär’s Theology.” In Rationalität in Der Islamischen Theologie: Band I: Die Klassische Periode, edited by Maha Elkaisy-Friemuth. De Gruyter, 2019.
Farsani, Yoones Dehghani, and Kianoosh Rezania. “Ibn Al-Malāḥimī on Zoroastrianism.” Iranian Studies 53, nos. 5–6 (2020): 703–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/00210862.2020.1713058.
Flick, Uwe. Managing Quality in Qualitative Research. Sage Publications, 2007.
Gimaret, Daniel. “Mu’tazila.” In The Encyclopaedia of Islam New Edition, vol. 7. Brill, 1993.
Griffel, Frank. “Theology Engages with Avicennan Philosophy: Al-Ghazālī’s Tahāfut al-Falāsifa and Ibn al-Malāḥimī’s Tuḥfat al-Mutakallimīn Fī l-Radd ‘alā l-Falāsifa.” In The Oxford Handbook of Islamic Theology, edited by Sabine Schmidtke. Oxford University Press, 2016.
Hilal, Muhammad. “Filsafat Bahasa Biasa Gilbert Ryle dan Relevansinya dengan Konsep Pendidikan Karakter di Indonesia.” Jurnal Filsafat 29, no. 2 (2019): 206–27. https://doi.org/10.22146/jf.44313.
Ibn al-Malāḥimī, Rukn al-Dīn. Kitāb Al-Fā’iq Fī Uṣūl al-Dīn. Edited by Fayṣal Badīr ‘Awn. Dār al-Kutub wa al-Wathā’iq al-Qawmiyyah, 2010.
Ibn al-Malāḥimī, Rukn al-Dīn. Tuḥfah Al-Mutakallimīn Fī al-Radd ‘alā al-Falāsifah. Edited by Sabine Schmidtke and Wilferd Madelung. Iranian Institute of Philosophy & Institute of Islamic Studies Freie University of Berlin, 2008.
Ibn al-Murtaḍā, Aḥmad ibn Yaḥyā. Kitāb Ṭabaqāt Al-Mu‘tazilah. Edited by Susanna Diwald-Wilzer. Maktabah al-Ḥayāh, 1961.
Ibn Mattawayh, Abū Muḥammad. Al-Majmū‘ Fī al-Muḥīṭ Bi al-Taklīf. Edited by Josef J. Houben s.j. and Daniel Gimaret. II. Dar el-Machreq, 1980.
Jhasim, Mohamed Saffah, and Nihad Humud Aswad. “Mawqif al-Mu‘tazilah min al-Nubuwwah.” Arab Scientific Heritage Journal 4, no. 4 (2015): 241–66. https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/110770.
Koertner, Mareike. Proving Prophecy: Dalā’il al-Nubūwa Literature as Part of the Scholarly Discourse on Prophecy in Islam. Brill, 2024.
Koloğlu, Orhan Şener. “Ibn Al-Malāḥimī’s Criticism of Philosophers’ Views on God’s Knowledge of Particulars.” Uludağ Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi 27, no. 2 (2018): 47–65. https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/uluifd/issue/41319/499530.
Madelung, Wilferd. “Ibn Al-Malāḥimī on the Human Soul.” The Muslim World 102, nos. 3–4 (2012): 426–32. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1478-1913.2012.01410.x.
Madelung, Wilferd. “Ibn Al-Malāḥimī’s Refutation of the Philosophers.” In A Common Rationality: Mu’tazilism in Islam and Judaism, edited by Camilia Adang, Sabine Schmidtke, and David Eric Sklare. Ergon, 2007.
Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna’s Psychological Proof of Prophecy.” Journal of Near Eastern Studies 22, no. 1 (1963): 49–56. https://www.jstor.org/stable/543930.
Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna’s Theory of Prophecy in the Light of Ash’arite Theology.” In The Seed of Wisdom: Essays in Honour of T. J. Meek, edited by W. S. McCullough. University of Toronto Press, 1964.
Mayhūb, Sayyid ‘Abd al-Sattār. Al-Qur’ān Wa al-Nubuwwah ‘Ind al-Qāḍī ‘Abd al-Jabbār. Dār al-Hidāyah, 1996.
Merriam, Sharan B., and Elizabeth J. Tisdell. Qualitative Research: A Guide to Design and Implementation. 4th ed. A Willey Brand, 2016.
Miles, Matthew B., and A. Michael Huberman. Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. 2nd ed. Sage Publications, 1994.
Rahman, Fazlur. Prophecy in Islam: Philosophy and Ortodoxy. Routledge, 1959.
Rakhmat, Aulia. “Kritik Mu’tazilah Terhadap Sistem Filsafat Ibn Sina: Analisis Pemikiran Taklif Ibn al-Malahimi.” Living Islam: Journal of Islamic Discourses 5, no. 1 (2022): 61–78. https://doi.org/10.14421/lijid.v5i1.3495.
Stroumsa, Sarah. Freethinkers of Medieval Islam: Ibn al-Rāwandī, Abū Bakr al-Rāzī, and Their Impact on Islamic Thought. Brill, 1999.
‘Uthmān, ‘Abd al-Karīm. Naẓariyyah Al-Taklīf: Ārā’ al-Qāḍī ‘Abd al-Jabbār al-Kalāmiyyah. Mu’assasah al-Risālah, 1971.
Walzer, Richard. “Al-Fārābī’s Theory of Prophecy and Divination.” The Journal of Hellenic Studies 77, no. 1 (1957): 142–48. https://doi.org/10.2307/628647.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Muhammad Hilal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
